UX is a unique field. It's grounded in understanding people and creating products that meet their needs. As such, it requires an empathetic approach in every aspect, including the feedback process. Let's dissect this journey and touch on some unconventional wisdom about providing and receiving feedback.
Tackling Feedback with Empathy
In UX, we use empathy to understand users, but it's just as important when interacting with our team. A feedback culture that emphasizes empathy not only strengthens relationships but also drives innovation.
Keep the Human Element in Mind
Remember, behind each design, there is a designer - a human with emotions, pride, and ambition. Be sure to phrase your feedback in a way that acknowledges their effort and perspective.
Consider this dialog:
Reviewer: "I appreciate the creativity of your navigation. However, considering our users, I worry that the flow might be too complex for some. What do you think about simplifying it?"
Designer: "I see your perspective. Let me try to streamline it more."
Here, the reviewer values the designer's work and raises a point by inviting a discussion rather than dictating changes.
Embracing Discomfort
Receiving feedback can sometimes be uncomfortable. But discomfort often signals growth. Learning to embrace it can help turn feedback into fuel for personal and professional development.
Breaking Down Feedback
When you receive feedback, break it down. Analyze the points raised, and separate the emotional response from the objective facts. Recognizing the validity of the feedback despite any emotional discomfort it causes can help you grow as a designer.
Feedback is Not Personal: It's About the Design
Let me restate the obvious: feedback in UX is about the design, not the designer. It's a conversation about how effectively the design solves the user's problem, and not a critique of the designer's skills.
For instance:
Reviewer: "The color scheme used for this layout option is remarkable. However, it might not be fully accessible for our visually impaired users. Can we adapt it to make it more inclusive?"
Designer: "You're right, I missed that aspect. I'll incorporate the changes."
Here, the feedback focuses on the design's effectiveness, not the designer's capability.
Active Listening - A Game Changer
Active listening is key in feedback sessions. It involves fully engaging in the conversation, asking clarifying questions, and summarizing the feedback to ensure understanding.
The Feedback Exchange
In UX, feedback cannot be a one-way street. It's not just about receiving feedback but also discussing and questioning it.
Reviewer: "The flow of the signup process seems long. Maybe we could shorten it?"
Designer: "I considered that, but our research showed users prefer a more detailed, step-by-step process. They feel it's more secure. Should we reconsider?"
Here, the designer takes an active role in the feedback process, promoting a healthy discussion.
The Art of Self-feedback
Finally, self-feedback is an often overlooked aspect. It involves critically analyzing your design before others do. It allows you to anticipate feedback points, prepare your responses, and improve your design ahead of time.
To wrap up, here are some key takeaways:
Feedback in UX is an empathetic conversation, not a personal critique.
Embrace the discomfort that feedback can bring, as it often signals growth.
Actively engage in the feedback process, don't just receive it.
Don't forget the art of self-feedback.
Creating a Feedback-Rich Culture
Nurturing a feedback-rich culture in your teammates isn't just about facilitating design critiques. It's about fostering an environment where everyone feels comfortable expressing their ideas and concerns. This can only happen when feedback is seen as a constructive tool rather than a personal attack.
Encourage Openness and Curiosity
If you are a UX leader, it’s up to you to set the tone of openness and curiosity on your team. Encourage team members to question, learn, and refine their ideas. This way, they see feedback as a chance for learning and innovation, not as a fault-finding mission.
For example:
Leader: "I see some fascinating approaches in your design. I wonder if there might be an alternative way to present this data that could be more intuitive for our users. What do you think?"
This approach invites collaboration and exploration, reframing feedback as an opportunity for improvement.
Deconstructing Hierarchies
In feedback sessions, try minimizing hierarchical barriers. Seniority shouldn't impede the flow of feedback. Ensure everyone's voice is heard and valued equally, regardless of their position.
Here's a dialog showcasing this:
Junior Designer: "I was thinking, maybe we can reorganize this page to follow a more F-pattern layout?"
Senior Designer: "That's an interesting perspective. Could you elaborate on how you think it might improve the user experience?"
This dialog illustrates how a culture of respect and openness can enable constructive feedback, regardless of hierarchy.
Celebrating Progress, Not Just Success
Reframe the concept of success for your team. Celebrate progress and growth, not just final success. This shift in focus encourages designers to take risks, learn from mistakes, and see feedback as a stepping stone towards progress, not as a setback.
Reflective Sessions
Incorporate reflective sessions into your routine. Here, each team member reflects on their work, shares self-feedback, and discusses the lessons learned. It's a powerful tool to foster a culture of continuous learning and improvement.
A Two-way Street
Remember, as a UX leader, feedback isn't just about giving but also receiving. Encourage team members to share feedback about your decisions and actions. It not only enhances team relationships but also models the feedback culture you're promoting.
To wrap up:
Nurture a feedback-rich culture that encourages openness, curiosity, and deconstructs hierarchies.
Celebrate progress, not just success.
Incorporate reflective sessions and encourage self-feedback.
Remember, feedback is a two-way street.
Feedback, when approached with empathy and openness, can be a transformative tool in UX. It has the potential to drive growth, innovation, and camaraderie in teams. So, let's turn this often-dreaded process into a constructive, collaborative conversation. Let's make feedback the catalyst for creating exceptional experiences.
—Marina
Want to learn more? A few ways I can help you.
Apply for a 1-on-1 UX mentorship to gain valuable insights, and boost your design career like never before.
Book a one-off 1-on-1 call if you need personalized advice without committing to a monthly UX mentorship.
Follow me on LinkedIn for short, free tips throughout the week.
If you aspire to become a UX mentor, check my book on Amazon.
I send weekly emails about UX leadership and mentorship, along with practical advice on weaving AI into your UX processes and mentorship programs.